Recent discussions highlight the increasing incidence of antisemitism in America, emphasizing that combating it requires more than mere denunciations of opposition to Israel or scrutiny of elite universities. As political figures, including Trump, assert they are tackling antisemitism, they risk perpetuating harmful stereotypes. University officials are facing backlash for perceived inaction amidst rising antisemitism concerns, with critics accusing them of cowardice. The situation raises alarm about the potential for scapegoating Jewish students, particularly in light of ongoing protests that some argue should not be debated. The discourse around American antisemitism prompts critical reflection on its implications and complexities.