As the Israel-Hamas war continues into its second year, students across American college campuses are reflecting on the ramifications of the ongoing conflict. Many express concerns about a growing 'chill' on free speech in academic settings, as protests and discussions about the war have escalated. Institutions are grappling with balancing safety and free expression, especially following previous protests that drew national attention. Meanwhile, student activists remain committed to their causes, with calls for divestment and advocacy for Palestinian rights gaining traction. The impact of this heightened activism is prompting colleges to reevaluate their policies on campus discourse, amid calls for more constructive conversations surrounding the Israel-Palestine conflict. Faculty and student leaders alike emphasize the importance of providing a platform for diverse viewpoints while navigating the complexities of free speech in today's charged political environment.