The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is considering a provocative new reality TV show concept where immigrants would compete for U.S. citizenship, a proposal that has sparked widespread criticism. Supporters, including DHS Secretary Kristi Noem, argue that the show could present immigration in an engaging format, while detractors have labeled the idea as inhumane and a distortion of the serious issue of immigration. As the DHS begins the initial vetting process for this entertainment concept, concerns about due process and the potential for commodifying the citizenship journey are at the forefront of public discourse. The network involved may include notable producers from reality television, indicating a serious departure from traditional immigration policy discussions.