As Afghanistan marks four years since the Taliban regained control following the U.S. withdrawal, the nation is grappling with dire humanitarian issues, including widespread human rights violations and severe food insecurity. The fallout from the exit of American troops has left many veterans reflecting on the consequences of the withdrawal, with some dubbing it one of the worst crises witnessed in recent history. Reports indicate that minority groups continue to face renewed oppression, while the Taliban seeks to establish strong ties with the United States amid a backdrop of deteriorating conditions. Experts and former officials express concern over the long-term implications of these developments, questioning whether the U.S. effectively chose defeat in Afghanistan and calling for measures to protect religious freedoms. The anniversary serves as a stark reminder of the challenges facing the Afghan population and the legacy of two decades of American involvement in the region.