The Supreme Court is currently deliberating a significant copyright dispute involving internet service providers (ISPs) and the music industry, marked by a billion-dollar lawsuit against Cox Communications by Sony Music. The case raises critical questions about the liability of ISPs in curbing online music piracy while balancing the potential repercussions on internet access for users. Justices have expressed skepticism about the extent to which ISPs should be required to police illegal downloads, with some indicating a possible inclination towards favoring ISPs in this contentious battle. As arguments unfold, there are concerns that a ruling could not only reshape copyright law but also impact internet access for all Americans.